We use cloth diapers. Mostly because it’s cheaper but also because it means we’re throwing less away. But cloth diaper companies will say there is a third advantage: Cloth diaper children are toilet trained on average a half year to a year earlier than disposable diaper children – or so they say.
The thought as to the reason behind this (I believe) is two-fold – parents don’t like dealing with Cloth diapers and children feel less comfortable with them, so both have a vested interest in getting beyond that stage as early as possible.
So the product benefit is actually a result of negative aspects of the product.
This got me thinking. Why don’t other products do this?
For example, a vacation rental place that isn’t very pleasant. Well, at least you will be pleased to get home after your vacation. And you make you feel like your home is nicer after a week at our place.
Or not-so-tasty ice cream – you’ll want to eat less, and it might help you lose weight.
Or televisions that don’t work well – your kids will want to spend more time outside!
I think this is a facet of marketing too often neglected. Ad companies, take note.
Can you think of other products that could benefit from this method?


3 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 23, 2009 at 8:27 am
Marketers, show people how the crappiness of your product will improve people’s lives. - 22 Words
[...] thinks other companies should perhaps try this, [...]
July 23, 2009 at 3:49 pm
T
You just reminded me of a movie I can never remember the name of, but distinctly remember watching as a kid: Crazy People. It was truly funny.
July 24, 2009 at 7:17 am
Chris
I have a dishwasher that has to be repaired about twice a year–sometimes more, at least once for each of two different problems. It doesn’t qualify for the lemon law because they never replace the same part three times in one year.
I guess the advertisers could say that you’ll be sure never to be embarrassed by food particles left on your dishes because you have to hold them up to the light every time you unload to be sure they’re really clean, due to the faulty design of this dishwasher.
And the department store where I bought it can say that you really, really, really get your moneysworth on the warranty payments because you will be getting free service a lot! And you’ll be sure to have a few mornings a year to just stay home and spend time doing what you want (reading, cleaning, sewing, or whatever) because you have to be home during that four hour window when the repairman could come, and he almost always comes at the end of the four hour window.
Somehow not quite as convincing as the potty training benefit…